MSC Reviews

LARGE PRINT WORKBENCH EDITION

POCKET SIZED EDITION

Does the Inside Back Cover of your book contain a hologram as pictured? If so, click here. If not, please continue leaving a review.

close [x]

*
*
*
*

*
*
*   Rating   1 2 3 4 5


* Review

General Comment

Pros

Cons


 

Mr

July 9, 2021 By: Tom Eastwood (Rochdale, United Kingdom)

Comments
If you're thinking about purchasing this book, don't think, just do it!

Pros
As in depth as you'll ever need for the workshop.

Cons
Non
 

Engineers Black Book V3

July 9, 2021 By: Michael Eales (South Guildford, Western Australia, Australia)

Comments
Real great book, and I am hard to please.

Pros
Has a Hugh range of information

Cons
Would like to see some more metric standards as well as the great imperial standards you have in here.
 

Handy little thing

July 8, 2021 By: Connor (Rowville, Australia)

Comments
I’m glad to now have this useful reference that I can have on me at all times!

 

Damn Handy

July 7, 2021 By: Zachary Evans, BHP (Melbourne, Australia)

Comments
Joked with one of the older tradesman that if he had forgotten anything I had a black book handy. Extremely useful book for all metal trades.

Cons
None
 

Really useful

July 3, 2021 By: Craig (Chelmsford, United Kingdom)

Comments
Very useful guide, good balance of size and information. Ring bound so can be opened and laid flat. Plenty of diagrams/pictures. Interesting small section on the history of engineering.

Pros
Easily cleaned pages (grease proof)
Useful but small size
Can be laid flat


Cons
None
 

Engineers Black Book

June 28, 2021 By: Stephen Ward (Oakdale, United States)

Comments
Useful information well made book

Pros
Packed full of useful information

Cons
None
 

Quick and easy to use

June 22, 2021 By: South40fab , South40 fabrication LLC (Curwensville , United States)

Comments
Much easier to use than my machinery’s handbook.

Pros
Lots of relevant information

Cons
None yet
 

Large Work Bench Edition

June 21, 2021 By: Dustin (Hammonton, United States)

Comments
Large Work Bench Edition - 3rd Edition

Even though they took away the gage and added clothing to the engineer man on the cover, I figured I'd take a shot at having this book on my desk as a quick reference. There is a lot of handy information within. You may need to overlook an odd sentence or an error here and there. Either way, at the end of the day, it's a neat book to have at your disposal.

Pros
-Lots of general information at your fingertips.
-Full color.
-Pages seem durable and easily wipe clean.
-Anti-glare works nicely under a shop light.
-Looks good on the desk (makes you look official).
-Large Work Bench Edition is easy to read and handle.
-Charts and images make it very convenient.
-The "Lay Flat Format" keeps your spot.

Cons
-I question how true "Actual Size" statements are with varying copy sizes.
-Page 50 calls out "HSS Step Drill" twice when on is a countersinking drill bit.
-The lack of a drill bit gauge is saddening; especially at the cost.
-A few errors with formulas and other references here and there.
-Heavy on some subjects while light on others.
-Google is typically a faster solution.
 

Tooling Engineer

June 14, 2021 By: Ryan Broderick (Belle River , Canada)

Comments
Very handy book, lots of great information

 

Great book i wish i knew before

June 13, 2021 By: Paul a Cote Sr, Home shop (Lewiston, United States)

Comments
great book im starting to use it more now glade i got it.

Pros
great book

Cons
the ring holes have been puch to close in one of the chapters its new like 3 holes on the top look like in not holding in the ring but its ok like 20 pages ty
 

Engineers Black Book

June 10, 2021 By: John and Tina Mostyn (WATANOBBI , Australia)

Comments
Great little pocket size, well bound, great material and references

 

Review of black book

June 9, 2021 By: Tyler atherton (Carlisle, United Kingdom)

Comments
Very informative

Pros
Excellent information covering vast amounts of detail

Cons
Some information not helpful such as adult physical dimensions
 

Apprentice

June 3, 2021 By: Harrison O'Hagan (ballarat, Australia)

Comments
Great Refrence books especially for Apprentices

Pros
there is all the information that you will need and more

Cons
pages 104 and 105 in the pocket and large editions say Actual size in relation to gear rack and pinion, but that can't be true as they are different sizes in each book
 

Ownet

June 2, 2021 By: Roy Wilson, Roy Wilson Woodworking (Mckinney, United States)

Comments
Great details and unbelievable scope of information

Pros
Love the size of the book makes it handy to keep close to the work

Cons
None, thanks
 

Excellent book

June 2, 2021 By: Martin van Schalkwyk (Kathu, South Africa)

Comments
That one book that contains mostly everything you need to know.

Pros
Made off very durable materials end will surely last a very long time. The information inside is laid out very clearly en needly and is very easy to understand.

Cons
Could not find any thus far.
 

Must Have Reference

May 31, 2021 By: David (Coogee, Australia)

Comments
Real handy to have in the shop, its got all the formulas and tables I need.

Pros
The best tool for decoding turning inserts I've ever used.

Cons
The section on sharpening HSS bits on page 68 should be moved to next to the turning formulas or carbide inserts, I can never find it when I need it. Also the third edition doesn't come with a drill guage.
 

Great Product!!

May 31, 2021 By: Jacob Crosbie (Mooroopna, Australia)

Comments
Great product! This book has everything I’ve needed to advance through my fabrication apprenticeship.

Pros
With so much knowledge all in a pocket-sized book, it’s made my job a million times easier.

Cons
It would be great if once purchasing the book you also had access to a digital copy as well, as I often leave my copy in the top draw of my toolbox at work and wish I’d had an extra copy when I tackle some extra jobs around home.
 

Staggering knowledge.

May 29, 2021 By: Barry Hann (San Jose, United States)

Comments
This is a small profile book of absolute importance. Saved me time off web searches and money from other references I was considering.

Pros
Vast Troves of Information in a compact design, page of interest index tabs.

Cons
Not much detail for end mills.
 

Senior Manufacturing Engineer

May 28, 2021 By: Joe (Belmont, Australia)

Comments
Must have book for amateurs and professionals alike

Pros
Detail on cutting tools is handy for those of us not on the machines every day

Cons
Some redundant content given the advent of calculators, would be good to see it replaced with a few basic speeds and feeds etc.
 

Fantastic

May 22, 2021 By: Elijah Kelsh (Dublin, Australia)

Comments
Absolute best compact book in my workshop. Don’t do many jobs without a quick reference from it.

Pros
Size/durability

Cons
I haven’t got the whole set yet